Hard Enamel vs Soft Enamel Pins: What's the Difference?

When creating custom enamel pins, one of the first production decisions is choosing between hard enamel and soft enamel.

Both styles use a metal base with colored enamel areas, but the finishing process creates noticeably different surface textures, visual effects, production costs, and overall appearances.

The right option depends on your artwork, desired texture, budget, quantity, and how the finished pins will be used.

What Is a Soft Enamel Pin?

With soft enamel pins, enamel color is filled into recessed areas of the metal design. The surrounding metal borders remain higher than the colored enamel, creating a noticeable textured surface.

When you run your finger across a soft enamel pin, you can usually feel the raised metal outlines. This texture is one of the main visual and physical characteristics of the process.

Soft Enamel Advantages

• Visible raised metal outlines
• Textured and dimensional surface
• Strong separation between colors and metal
• Works well with bold linework and illustrated designs
• Often more economical for comparable specifications
• Suitable for both small and larger production runs

Things to Consider

Because the colored areas remain recessed, the surface is not completely flat. If your design requires a smooth, polished, jewelry-like finish, hard enamel may be more suitable.

Explore our Custom Soft Enamel Pins .

What Is a Hard Enamel Pin?

With hard enamel pins, enamel is filled into the recessed areas and the surface goes through additional finishing and polishing. The goal is to bring the enamel and surrounding metal lines to a nearly level surface.

The result is a smooth, polished appearance with little or no noticeable surface texture when you run your finger across the face of the pin.

Hard Enamel Advantages

• Smooth and polished surface
• Clean, refined appearance
• Suitable for premium merchandise and presentation
• Works well for logos and designs that benefit from a flat finish
• Popular for corporate, recognition, and collector projects

Things to Consider

Hard enamel generally requires additional filling, finishing, and polishing compared with soft enamel. For otherwise similar specifications, this can result in a higher production cost.

Explore our Custom Hard Enamel Pins .

Hard Enamel vs Soft Enamel: Quick Comparison

Which Enamel Pin Type Is Better for Detailed Artwork?

Both hard enamel and soft enamel can work with detailed artwork, but the design still needs to be suitable for metal-and-enamel production.

Soft enamel visually emphasizes raised metal outlines and recessed areas, so it can work especially well when linework and texture are part of the design.

Hard enamel emphasizes a cleaner, flatter and more polished surface.

However, very small text, extremely thin metal lines, tiny color areas, and narrow gaps can cause production problems with either process.

Which Looks More Premium: Hard or Soft Enamel?

Hard enamel is commonly chosen when the project calls for a smooth and polished presentation. This makes it popular for premium merchandise, corporate programs, recognition pins, and collector products.

However, this does not mean soft enamel is a lower-quality product. Soft enamel intentionally uses raised metal lines and recessed color to create a different visual style.

For illustrated artwork, bold outlines, vintage-style designs, or products where texture is part of the concept, soft enamel may provide the appearance the designer is trying to achieve.

Which Is More Durable: Hard Enamel or Soft Enamel?

Both hard and soft enamel pins can perform well when they are properly manufactured, handled, and stored.

Hard enamel's flat polished surface can offer greater resistance to some types of surface abrasion because the enamel sits nearly level with the metal.

Soft enamel has recessed color areas protected by surrounding raised metal lines, but its textured surface behaves differently under wear.

For most merchandise, brand, event, and collector projects, the decision should usually be based on the desired appearance and production requirements rather than assuming that one process is automatically “high quality” and the other is “low quality.”

Why Does Hard Enamel Usually Cost More?

Both processes involve multiple manufacturing stages, including artwork preparation, mold making, metal forming, plating, coloring, assembly, inspection, and packaging.

Hard enamel generally requires additional enamel filling, finishing, and polishing to create its smooth, nearly level surface. Those extra manufacturing steps are one reason it often costs more than a comparable soft enamel design.

Enamel type is only one part of the quote. Other pricing factors can include:

• Pin size and thickness
• Order quantity
• Artwork complexity
• Number of colors
• Metal plating
• Custom shapes or cutouts
• Glitter or translucent enamel
• Screen printing or UV printing
• Backing type and number of posts
• Backing cards or custom packaging
• Shipping destination

For a more complete pricing breakdown, read our Custom Enamel Pin Cost Guide .

Hard Enamel vs Soft Enamel by Project Type

The table below shows common choices rather than strict rules. The final process should still be selected based on your artwork, budget, quantity, and desired appearance.

Does Pin Size Affect Which Enamel Type You Should Choose?

Size can influence how well small details translate into production, but there is no fixed rule that a particular pin size must use hard or soft enamel.

Smaller pins usually require simpler artwork, while larger pins provide more room for text, color areas, and detailed illustrations.

Before changing enamel type to solve a detail problem, it may be more useful to adjust the pin size or simplify a small part of the artwork.

Read our Enamel Pin Size Guide for more information.

Can You Add Special Effects to Hard and Soft Enamel Pins?

Yes. Depending on the artwork and manufacturing requirements, custom pins can include additional processes or decorative effects.

Options may include:

• Glitter enamel
• Glow-in-the-dark enamel
• Translucent enamel
• Screen printing
• UV printing
• Specialty plating
• Antique metal finishes

Not every effect is suitable for every design, so these options should be reviewed together with the artwork before production.

Hard Enamel vs Soft Enamel: Which Should You Choose?

There is no universal winner between hard enamel and soft enamel. The right choice depends on what you want the finished product to look and feel like.

Consider soft enamel if:

• You want raised metal lines and visible texture.
• Your artwork benefits from depth and strong metal outlines.
• You are producing artist merchandise, event pins, or promotional products.
• You want a more economical process for comparable specifications.

Consider hard enamel if:

• You want a flat, smooth, polished surface.
• You prefer a clean and refined presentation.
• The pins are intended for corporate, recognition, premium, or collector use.
• The artwork is designed to work well with a level surface.

If you are still unsure, do not choose based only on the product name. The most useful approach is to review the actual artwork, size, quantity, budget, and intended use together.

What Information Should You Send for a Recommendation?

To help determine the most suitable enamel process, send as much of the following information as possible:

• Your artwork, logo, sketch, or design idea
• Approximate pin size
• Quantity
• Desired surface: textured or smooth
• Preferred plating
• Any special effects
• Packaging requirements
• Delivery country
• Required delivery date

PixelToPin custom enamel pin production starts from 50 pieces. If you do not know all of the specifications yet, send us your artwork and approximate quantity first.

Hard Enamel Pins   ·   Soft Enamel Pins   ·   Real Production Examples